876 East Avenue &
104 Mathis Place Mantoloking
Two Adjacent Properties Sold Together
BLOCK 12, LOT 1: 68 x 110 / 0.1717 acres – LIST PRICE: $4,100,000
BLOCK 12, LOT 2: 60 x 120 / 0.1653 acres – List Price: $2,195,000
Introduction
MAGNIFICENT MANTOLOKING ESTATE * IDEAL LOCATION
Welcome to 876 East Avenue, a rare and storied offering, on the most prestigious street, in the heart of Mantoloking. Set across two lots, totaling 128′ x 230′, this classic shingle style residence blends timeless architecture with refined, traditional details.
Held within the same family for generations, the home captures the charm and grace of a bygone era. A sun-drenched living room with a traditional fireplace, an elegant formal dining room designed for large gatherings, and a south-facing open porch create a warm and inviting setting. From this porch, enjoy gentle afternoon breezes, the rhythm of East Avenue, and Mantoloking’s unforgettable sunsets—hallmarks of true coastal living.
Ideally located just steps from the beach and two blocks from the bay, this property offers both proximity and prestige. It is in the heart of the Gold Coast, where the most prominent shore properties are aligned in just a short stretch of blocks. The expansive, level grounds feature lush lawns, mature plantings, a large detached garage and an abundance of space for bikes, boards, parking, beach gear and all things summer.
When not unwinding at the seasonally life-guarded beaches, take a short stroll or easy bike ride to the Bay Head Yacht Club, Mantoloking Yacht Club and beloved local favorites including, Charlies of Bay Head, Mueller’s Bakery, Burke’s Market, Coffee at Noon, along with nearby local tennis and pickleball courts and charming shops.
Comprising of two properties — 876 East Avenue & 104 Mathis Place — this offering presents privacy, scale and opportunity. Sold together and AS IS, these separate properties provide the rare chance to renovate, expand or create one or two extraordinary custom dream homes in one of the Jersey Shore’s most prestigious enclaves.
Highlights
- Wonderful Mantoloking classic, shingle style, coastal Colonial in the ideal East Avenue location, set atop large property (68′ x 110′)
- A separate and adjoining lot (60′ x 120′) at 104 Mathis Place
- Gorgeous curb appeal with open porches and classic detailing
- Elegant living room with large windows and wood-burning fireplace with traditional mantel
- Formal dining room with windows on two sides and adjoins the kitchen with butlers pantry and bar area
- Open, south-facing porch for relaxing after a morning sail on Barnegat Bay, tennis game or day at the beach
- Six spacious bedrooms and two full bathroom span the 2nd & 3rd floors, each with multiple windows and an abundance of character
- 2nd floor sleeping porch, perfect to enjoy afternoon breezes or a mid-day nap
- Large unfinished basement for tons of storage
- Mature lawn and plantings with an underground sprinkler system
- IDEAL location — bike or walk to EVERYTHING: Bay Head Yacht Club, Mantoloking Yacht Club, Charlies of Bay Head, Burke’s Market, Coffee at Noon, tennis and pickleball courts or peruse nearby charming shops and restaurants
- Convenient distance from NJ commuter suburbs, Metropark, the Bay Head train station & only one and a half hour drive from NYC
